Man, 72, sues cops for $5
million over dustup
A 72-year-old man is suing the NYPD for a whopping $5 million, charging a group of plainclothes cops roughed him up on an upper Manhattan street .
A 72-year-old man is suing the NYPD for a whopping $5 million, charging a group of plainclothes cops roughed him up on an upper Manhattan street .
Otto Kogen said he had just
finished cleaning an apartment he rents out on W. 105th St. near Columbus Ave.
when he stepped out to his car about 6:30 p.m. on April 17, 2011.
Before he could get the keys
out of his pocket, three men slammed the frail 5-foot-4, 140-pound Kogen
against his 2004 Nissan Sentra.
“I thought they (were) robbing
me,” recalled the Latvia-born Kogen, who lives in Jersey City with his longtime
wife, Bella, and spends his spare time refurbishing antiques.
The men began rifling through
his pockets, so Kogen threatened to call the police.
That’s when Kogen said one of
the men flashed his badge.
“F--k you, Russian — we are
the police,” the officer replied, according to court papers.
“I was in shock,” Kogen said.
Kogen managed to flag down a
marked police cruiser, but the uniformed officers left after they realized he
was undergoing a stop-and-frisk, the court papers show.
Soon after, the plainclothes
cops left — and Kogen called 911 because he had chest pains. He spent the next
two days at Roosevelt Hospital.
According to police reports,
the officers said that they identified themselves nearly a dozen times when
they stopped Kogen because he appeared disheveled and intoxicated.
An NYPD spokeswoman said the
officers’ story was cleared by detectives from the department’s Internal
Affairs Bureau.
“It’s a lie,” said Kogen. “I
don’t drink.”
Hospital records show that no
alcohol was in his blood when he was admitted.
Kogen filed several
complaints, including one with the Civilian Complaint Review Board. Then he
decided to call a lawyer — Evan Nass — who in February filed the
multimillion-dollar suit.
The CCRB investigation later
found the claims “unsubstantiated,” mainly because there were no witnesses to
corroborate Kogen’s claims.
“Please understand, I
appreciate all police,” Kogen said. “(But) they’re not supposed to do this.”